Issue date: 3/15/07 Section: News
Dershowitz: Anti-semitism rising
Criminal lawyer, activist gives lecture to sold-out crowd
Julie Cohn
|
Dershowitz, also a Harvard law professor, spoke last night in the Zellerbach Theater for the fourth-annual Israel Awareness event.
Although slated to speak on global terrorism, the talk focused instead on the alarming rise of anti-semitism and what Dershowitz described as growing "delegitimization" of Israel.
The talk, running over two hours to an audience sold out by Monday, was heated and fast-paced and even included a brief outburst during the question-and-answer session that required security guards to remove a disruptive audience member.
The night started out with disconcerting statistics of European anti-semitism. According to Malcolm Hoenlein, vice chairman of the Congress of Jewish Presidents and opening speaker for Dershowitz, BBC polls have shown that 56 percent of Europeans find Israel to be "the most disgusting nation in the world," and that, in the United States, Jews are four times more likely to be the victims of hate than their Muslim counterparts.
Both Dershowitz and Hoenlein contended that anti-Israeli sentiments were for the most part redirected feelings of anti-semitism. "It's not politically correct to attack a Jew openly," Hoenlein said. "So they attack the state that represents them."
Dershowitz, an avid civil rights activist, openly voiced his dismay at recent human rights organizations for their misguided focus on Israel over what he sees as other, more pressing issues.
The Human Rights Watch, he noted, wrongly claimed that Hezbollah, a militant Islamic group based in Lebanon, never hid their forces behind Lebanese civilians in an attempt to demonize Israeli military actions in last summer's war, even after well-documented evidence to the contrary surfaced.
Groups like Human Rights Watch "have become human wrongs organizations," Dershowtiz said. "They spend more time [focused] on Israel … than on Darfur, more time on Israel … than on cultural genocide in Tibet."
College senior Aaron Rock said that "Dershowitz is very effective as an advocate for Israel and comes across as very reasonable."
Gabriela Kipnis, also College senior, added that "it was empowering to hear an academic and intelligent moderate speak on the issue - he was tremendously fair."



Viewing Comments 1 - 10 of 19
js
posted 3/15/07 @ 9:46 AM EST
I'd like to find out more about the situation with the PoliSci department and crackpot Finkelstein (raised during the talk and Q&A last night).
Hi there
posted 3/15/07 @ 9:48 AM EST
"criminal lawyer Alan Dershowitz"
Better editorial judgment perhaps, DP?
Shocked
posted 3/15/07 @ 10:18 AM EST
why was there no mention of the security issue that took place, when a guy started screaming at dershowitz and had to be lead out? the entire audience was booing him!
Penn grad
posted 3/15/07 @ 2:59 PM EST
Ridiculous. People have legitimate concerns about Israel's foreign policy and treatment of Palestinians, and it's sad that someone known as a defender of free speech is attempting to trivialize and ultimately squelch any criticism of Israel by labeling it "anti-Semitism," thus diverting any dialogue on the matter into a highly charged, overly rhetorical racial issue. (Continued…)
graduate
posted 3/15/07 @ 3:05 PM EST
So if we're against Israel's policies, we're anti-semitic? This is the same guy who called opposition to Bush's war on terror unpatriotic and anti-American. (Continued…)
learned_foot
posted 3/15/07 @ 5:08 PM EST
dershowitz is a joke. does anyone take seriously anything he says?
learned_foot
posted 3/16/07 @ 7:31 PM EST
umm, aside from the ad hominem attacks, who cares about whether dershowitz is a harvard law prof or great appellate lawyer? what does that have to do with anything? by the way, i'm not impressed with law. (Continued…)
Undergrad Penn
posted 3/18/07 @ 11:34 PM EST
My question is why does a DP "News" item take on such an editorial tone? Additionally, is it appropriate to mention only two quotes from students who felt the speaker was fair and moderate? It was most certainly not difficult to find a student representing the other view. (Continued…)
student
posted 3/19/07 @ 4:31 PM EST
Did anybody catch what was written on that guy's shirt? The conspiracy theorist?
Jai Mann
posted 3/22/07 @ 4:34 PM EST
Which guy? Dershowitz? Hoenlein? the Questioner? You've got two guys supporting the official conspiracy theory on stage and one guy supporting an alternative conspiracy theory. (Continued…)
Post a Comment